Not admitted · Not a forecast
Rules 1.1.0 · as of 14 Sep 2026
Owen Scott Muir · Said 7 Jul 2023 · owen-0597
Quote
Not a forecast
“This implies eliminating HIPAA, and without a federal right to privacy, class action lawsuits on privacy matters in federal court would be inapplicable.”
Core legal thesis: applying Justice Alito's Dobbs logic, healthcare privacy becomes a state matter; without a federal privacy right, federal privacy class actions (such as the one against Cerebral and other telehealth companies) would not be viable.
Descriptive, retrospective, or a statement of preference; no future state asserted.